Listening too intently?

In our little corner of the world there seems to be an increasing and almost scary reliance on, and acceptance of, what we are told is “good”, “right” and “better” by the magazines, websites and marketing big shots of the cycling industry.  Be it weight, technology, gear count or (*yawn*) disc brakes on road bikes, I can’t help thinking too many of us are listening too intently.

Year-in and year-out the bike industry busily churns out the “next best thing”, with annual 10% reductions in weight and 10% increases in stiffness.  Everything has gone oversize on the basis that stiffer and lighter is “better”.  Rims have gone wider, and ‘aero’ rims are no longer ‘aero’ unless they have a bulbous curve to them.  On the subject of which, every bike brand now has an ‘aero’ frame in their range, and every helmet manufacturer has an ‘aero’ lid to match.  Jeepers…

Cranks are apparently getting stiffer and lighter.  Anyone who can ride two different cranksets on the same bike and tell me they can genuinely, physically feel the difference in weight or stiffness… well, you can have all my bikes.  Oversize head tubes on steel frames?  Nothing more than following fashion of other materials (where, admittedly, this might have a benefit above a certain frame sizes).  30mm BBs and crank axles?  Shimano certainly aren’t shifting on this, and one American shop who test a lot of components have, so I’m reliably informed, proven that 30mm axles carry zero benefit Vs 24mm axles.  35mm bars and stems?  Really?

Don’t get me wrong – some of this stuff is genuinely very good, regardless of whether or not the ‘benefits’ truly exist.  Praxis’ second brand, Turn, have some new cranks on the market – the quality is outstanding, but I’m curious whether they really need to have 30mm axles on them, beyond a requirement to be more universal to all of the BB ‘standards’ out there now that we’ve all been told (brainwashed?) that the 30mm axles are “better”.

And then there’s the respected, experienced few who are given the privilege of testing “the latest and greatest” to tell us all how wonderful these new-fangled technologies are. I admit to being one of those few – but if I don’t like a product enough to offer up a positive review I politely decline, choosing instead to give the company my criticisms and feedback.  A less proactive example of us respected, experienced few, is a widely regarded website who openly state that their method of testing the stiffness of a bike frame is to lean it up against a wall and push against the pedal.  What is that actually testing?  Not a lot beyond the movement of the tyres and stiffness of the wheels – any bottom bracket movement resulting from this ‘methodology’ would only be visible to the naked eye, and that’s no means of measurement.  Use the same tyres at the same pressure, on the same wheels, at the same spot on the same wall, with markings on the ground to check the BB movement using a camera lens mounted at the same height and pointing at the same angle and I might start to buy into it.  And yet their readers listen.

I ride “old style” narrow rims, and even some tubular rims that are over ten years old (granted, I do own a set of new-fangled wide rims too).  None of my current bikes has an oversize headset, and recently I was running a ten year old steel frame that had a 1” headset on it (admittedly, I do have a frame on the way that will have a 44mm head tube).  I don’t own a carbon bike, and one of my bikes is made of wood.  Yes, really.  Ok so I do have a bike that runs electronic gears, and yes, they work very nicely – but they also bore me to tears because there’s no maintenance to do.  My bike with an oversize PressFit30 BB has been nothing but a ballache, and I run a BB that converts it back to a 24mm axle.  Go figure!

Don’t get me wrong – I’m often an early adopter, and I love the ‘latest and greatest’, but only when it carries an actual, tangible benefit.  Frankly I struggle to remember the last time a new bike product made me feel any genuine performance benefit or enhancement beyond making my bike look better.

And the disc brakes on road bikes thing?  I’m not going there…


More Opinions...

How To Tidy Cabling

A little while back, my good lady wife’s bike was in need of a spring clean so I took the opportunity to finally cover something I’ve been meaning to do for ages – cables. But this is not so much a ‘how to setup and tune your brakes and gears’ and more like ‘how to keep…

Go on then, tell me more...!


Didn’t I already write a bit on what I thought of the crotchety old men of the UCI and bicycle design?

Go on then, tell me more...!

SeaSucker Review

Our car was big enough for all of the baby stuff plus her bike, surely?

Go on then, tell me more...!

earHero Review

Headphone use on bikes is always a hotly debated internet forum topic…

Go on then, tell me more...!

Fit for use

Last week it happened, I met the ground with a thud.

Go on then, tell me more...!

The Schlumpf

It’s every rider’s little dirty secret. I’m sure it’s the same theory for all activities, but for cycling deep in the back of every cyclist’s mind they secretly like to think themselves as being ‘hardmen’. Some just think it, others are quite overt about it but either way it lingers there, simmering under the surface.…

Go on then, tell me more...!

The Hype Cycle

I’m allergic to production bikes. Ok, that’s not strictly true, but I will generally avoid most production machines – usually based an irrational dislike of the brand, a less irrational dislike of the available colourschemes, ill-suited geometry or a combination of the above. Recently, on the hunt for a new project, I had a (rather…

Go on then, tell me more...!

Bikes are boring

I bet that title caught your attention!? Let me expand on that. Bicycle ‘design’ is boring and I mean both in terms of visual appeal and in terms of design and designing. It’s funny when you think about it but somehow, in the world of bicycles, we seem to have ended up with a never…

Go on then, tell me more...!

Be seen – Orfos bike light review

Orfos lights started as one of those Kickstarter campaigns that did rather well. What was the final result…?

Go on then, tell me more...!

What Type of Cyclist Are You?

At the London round of the Rollapaluza National Series during the week a conversation got my cogs whirring… Nick Hussey, Damien Breen (of that most excellent In The Saddle blog) and myself were talking – it was like a mini bloggers convention (although not ‘mini’ in that any of us are particularly short I might…

Go on then, tell me more...!