Not until the fundamental changes…

I was reading the other day on some mountain bike forum that such and such a bike looks like some other brand’s bike. It’s not the first time this has come up and it’s not going to be the last. What it signifies though is that ‘that’ particular avenue has gone as far as it can go.

It’s something I ponder quite a bit – ‘where to next?’ to put it another way. In the case of say a mountain bike frame, there literally are so many ways you can stick the various bits together and do so in an effective manner. Truth be known, the very best, lightest and strongest way to do it (with metal) is with round tubes in the form of a triangle. Sorry folks, but that’s the truth. Every departure from this is just ‘design’, some better executions than others, some more purposeful than others.

Motorcycles and cars are the same deal. The ‘package’ has been refined as far is it’s going to get, everything over this really, again, is aesthetic design to please the eye, and while marketing departments will tell you that the shapes are for aerodynamic, fuel saving purposes, the truth is that a truly aerodynamic car is pretty boring – Prius anyone? Unlike the humble bicycle though, cars and many moto’s have a skin than can be shaped into a pleasing shape, so there is always somewhere to go with them.

It occurred to me (not recently mind you) that for something to really change, a fundamental factor has to shift first. For a car, that might mean loosing the ICE (internal combustion engine), which would mean that the entire package of the car could change, depending on what replaces the ICE. The same can be said for a moto. Slap an electric motor in there and suddenly a whole host of components are no longer needed and as a result, the overall package can change.

Look Ma, no tank…

In the case of a bicycle, it’s a much harder call, there just are no superfluous parts on a bike, or complex systems that require additional components, which means that something more significant has to change. The immediate thing that comes to mind is the drivetrain. That mashing of chain, derailleurs, sprockets, is what keeps a bike looking the way it does. If you’ve ever tried to design around that wretched combo, you’ll know what a limiting pain it is. Loose the lot, or at least the gears (in a conventional sense) and you’ll open the door to a word of new and fresh design possibilities – shaft dive, enclosed belt drives, central gear boxes, each one of those things can change the fundamental package of the frame to the point that a bicycle could look remarkably different.

Will it happen? Well that’s the next question and seeing at what a desperately slow and uninspired pace the bike industry moves in, it’s hard to say if it will. There have been attempts, no doubt, and options are there but I am guessing until there is a substantial uptake of an alternate technology, we will continue to see bikes be a rehash of the same old, same old.

… just thinking aloud.


More Opinions...

How To Tidy Cabling

A little while back, my good lady wife’s bike was in need of a spring clean so I took the opportunity to finally cover something I’ve been meaning to do for ages – cables. But this is not so much a ‘how to setup and tune your brakes and gears’ and more like ‘how to keep…

Go on then, tell me more...!


Didn’t I already write a bit on what I thought of the crotchety old men of the UCI and bicycle design?

Go on then, tell me more...!

SeaSucker Review

Our car was big enough for all of the baby stuff plus her bike, surely?

Go on then, tell me more...!

earHero Review

Headphone use on bikes is always a hotly debated internet forum topic…

Go on then, tell me more...!

Fit for use

Last week it happened, I met the ground with a thud.

Go on then, tell me more...!

The Schlumpf

It’s every rider’s little dirty secret. I’m sure it’s the same theory for all activities, but for cycling deep in the back of every cyclist’s mind they secretly like to think themselves as being ‘hardmen’. Some just think it, others are quite overt about it but either way it lingers there, simmering under the surface.…

Go on then, tell me more...!

The Hype Cycle

I’m allergic to production bikes. Ok, that’s not strictly true, but I will generally avoid most production machines – usually based an irrational dislike of the brand, a less irrational dislike of the available colourschemes, ill-suited geometry or a combination of the above. Recently, on the hunt for a new project, I had a (rather…

Go on then, tell me more...!

Bikes are boring

I bet that title caught your attention!? Let me expand on that. Bicycle ‘design’ is boring and I mean both in terms of visual appeal and in terms of design and designing. It’s funny when you think about it but somehow, in the world of bicycles, we seem to have ended up with a never…

Go on then, tell me more...!

Be seen – Orfos bike light review

Orfos lights started as one of those Kickstarter campaigns that did rather well. What was the final result…?

Go on then, tell me more...!

What Type of Cyclist Are You?

At the London round of the Rollapaluza National Series during the week a conversation got my cogs whirring… Nick Hussey, Damien Breen (of that most excellent In The Saddle blog) and myself were talking – it was like a mini bloggers convention (although not ‘mini’ in that any of us are particularly short I might…

Go on then, tell me more...!